"There are no atheists in foxholes."
"I prayed for twenty years but received no answer until I prayed with my legs."
-Frederick Douglass
"I put no stock in religion. By the word religion I have seen the lunacy of fanatics of every denomination be called the will of god. I have seen too much religion in the eyes of too many murderers. Holiness is in right action, and courage on behalf of those who cannot defend themselves, and goodness. What god desires is here [points to head] and here [points to heart] and what you decide to do every day, you will be a good man - or not." -The Kingdom of Heaven
***
I have two pretty solid rules when I'm out with friends: Don't discuss politics, and don't discuss religion. I really like discussing politics, so I'll bend that rule if somebody brings something up. But I'm not about to bring a rousing game of quarters to a halt by announcing, "Hey! How does everybody feel about abortion!?"
Religion is in a different category. Will not discuss it. Quite possibly the worst thing you can discuss after people have been drinking. And I'm usually hanging out in Ann Arbor, where, you know, people have different religions. It's not exactly the
University of Dayton (please, hold the hate texts on that one).
But then cancer comes along and I don't really have a doubt that people have wondered about this. Not in a narcissistic, "I'm really wondering if Nick has come to God yet?" way, but more like, "What impact does something like this have on your religious views?"
And man, I put a lot of thought into this. I was really on the fence for a long time. I've really only had one or two friends who have conjured up the courage to ask me about this, but I've received enough religious cards, tokens, prayers, that I know this is major component of dealing with cancer. I just didn't know what or how to write about it because my thoughts on the subject are so scattered. But writing here helps me un-scatter my thoughts, so maybe it wouldn't be all bad. And who says I have to come to any conclusion? I don't think that would even be possible. Seems a little presumptuous.
But then I woke up on Sunday morning in a writing mood. I had my first cancer dream just before I woke up on Sunday. It was actually pretty good and I remember most of it. I was talking with three other people, about my age, about my diagnosis and treatment and the whole experience. I don't remember the exact questions they asked me, but I remember I didn't like the three people. They were spoiled or bratty or something (shut up, none of this has to make sense. I'm writing about a dream like 12 hours later). But I spoke to them with such conviction and clarity in my thoughts. I was impressed with my dreamy self. I remember the gist of what I've said, but it's nothing I haven't already said here. But I was doing in my dream pretty much what I do here - telling people who want to know what I know, what I know. Conveying the reality of the experience. Putting a face on it, as some people have told me.
So I woke up, looked at my pillow, said, "Shit that's a lot of hair" for like the 5th day in a row, and decided, what the hell, I'll do the religion post. It was the Sabbath and all. And apparently we've been
burning feces-smeared holy books all weekend. So there really wasn't a better time to get after it.
***
I love good quotes, but I only remember them if they mean something to me. I hate vapid, meaningless quotes that too often are used when an author can't come up with a meaningful opening.
But the ones listed above, collectively, could not do a better job of characterizing my varying and sometimes-conflicting thoughts on this topic.
I've discussed my varying thoughts on the describing-cancer-with-battle-imagery thing. I don't like it, generally. And you certainly don't feel like you're "fighting" anything when you're sitting in the treatment chair. But there are some pretty strong parallels - namely the life-or-death nature of the struggle. This might be, and hopefully will be, as close to that sort of struggle as I'll ever get.
So yeah, I'm in a foxhole of sorts. And nope, I don't see too many atheists in my foxhole. I'm not the most religious guy on earth, but I'm not exactly reading
Richard Dawkins in the treatment room.
And I pray. Every night before I go to sleep. And I've done this for about as long as I can remember. Which is good, because the Bible is not too kind (nor are humans) to people to people who come begging for help only when they need it. Nobody likes it when a friend or acquaintance pulls this stuff; I can't imagine God is very fond of it either.
I'm very accepting of the prayers, gifts, and tokens from others. I've received a lot of that stuff, and it really does mean a lot to me. I know I have Christians, Muslims and Jews praying for me. When I'm done with this, I'm going to go work my game at Camp David or something. If only half the people who said they were putting me on prayer lists actually followed through, I'm still on about 15 of them. I have so many prayers going to so many gods or deities or beings from so many different religions, I can't really keep them all straight. My bases, they are covered.
Does it help? I don't know. That's the thing with religion: you just don't know these things. That's why its called "faith." But I know it certainly doesn't hurt. If nothing else, it has a positive effect on my mental state. I'll get into that more in a later post, but suffice to say I'm beginning to realize that that has more of an effect on things than I previously realized.
You don't see a lot of the religious stuff around here, and that's pretty much just because I'm not like that. I never have been. And I'm not going to change now just because something bad happened to me, because that would just be feigned, contrived BS. It would be an act. It would insult my own intelligence. It would insult people who really do have a different brand of faith or express it in different ways. And I'm pretty sure it would be insulting to God as well.
***
But then,
Frederick Douglass. If you want to graduate from Michigan with a degree in one of the social sciences, you will have to read some very important pieces of literature on multiple occasions. Over my 4 years there, I was assigned
Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass twice,
The Port Huron Statement three times, and
Thomas Sugrue's
Origins of the Urban Crisis three times. If you want to read lesser-important authors like Jefferson, Madison, Hamilton, Paine, etc., well...you gotta hope to find the right class. And you can check out the Constitution on your own time.
Political kvetching aside, I rather like Frederick Douglass as a writer. The man had some perspective. The man had some experiences. And he had a way of communicating that perspective and experience to an audience (whitey) that either didn't know or didn't sympathize with his situation. He wrote with a purpose and he wrote well. And he knew hardship better than most.
Frederick Douglass was a slave in Maryland (that state is really not getting a lot of love here) in the mid 19th century. He taught himself how to read and write, and escaped from Maryland into New York when he was about 20 years old. And he had this to say about praying during his captivity:
I prayed for twenty years but received no answer until I prayed with my legs.
I know there are a ton of people who are struggling and have struggled with cancer. I know there are a ton of extremely religious and devoted people who are struggling with cancer. I admit I don't know the details of everybody's struggle. But I have yet to hear about an individual who told doctors, "Thanks, but I'm going to pass on chemo. I'm going to church." I mean, I'm sure it's happened. But the vast majority of people are "praying with their legs."
You do not come down with cancer at age 25 and not wonder why. You sit there, and you think about how you've tried to do the right things, tried to live your life in a positive manner. You know you've made mistakes, but seriously...cancer? And why me, an admittedly not-exceptionally-religious or churchgoing guy, but one prays every night and who can point to some pretty great things he's done in life? And can point to a hell of a lot more people who don't do those things but aren't currently dealing with their hair falling out every time they sneeze.
Of course, I don't need the irrationality of these thoughts explained to me. That's why it took me a few seconds to get over them. Of course they're dumb. Of course there aren't any good answers. I know this.
But it also makes me pretty incapable of "putting my faith in God" and "trusting the plan the good Lord has for me." I don't need to get into the whole, "If God couldn't prevent this/If God could prevent this and didn't" debate. It's not necessary. It's just the way I think.
Brief Christopher Hitchens interlude. Imagine me and my cantankerosity aged about 40 years and you have Hitchens. Love his writing. Not the best guy to soothe your feelings about cancer. Background: Hitchens is an avowed atheist who came down with some form of throat cancer. He writes about his experience. In his
latest piece for Vanity Fair, he reprinted a comment from a reader. It's not very nice:
Who else feels Christopher Hitchens getting terminal throat cancer [sic] was God’s revenge for him using his voice to blaspheme him? Atheists like to ignore FACTS. They like to act like everything is a “coincidence”. Really? It’s just a “coincidence” [that] out of any part of his body, Christopher Hitchens got cancer in the one part of his body he used for blasphemy? Yea, keep believing that Atheists. He’s going to writhe in agony and pain and wither away to nothing and then die a horrible agonizing death, and THEN comes the real fun, when he’s sent to HELLFIRE forever to be tortured and set afire.
See? Not very nice, right. Although I'm pretty positive that nobody who reads this site harbors these feelings toward me. At least, I haven't received any reader responses that indicate as such.
But seriously, is this guy that out of line? I mean, do you really think there isn't support in the scriptures for this sort of stuff? I've actually read good chunks of the Bible. Not really out of any sort of strong devotional obligation, but just because I like to know about stuff and I don't want to be caught discussing things I don't understand. I've read parts of the Torah and Quran as well (I took a religion class in undergrad - extremely fascinating stuff, especially since it was for an educational purpose). I admit I don't have highlighted and annotated copies of all the holy works, but I've consumed enough religious material to know that these things say
a lot of stuff.
So who's to say he's wrong? I could probably find an awful lot of support in scripture for that dude's reasoning. Hell, I could probably do it for every single one of you. I'm a lawyer. If you gave me two items: one, a Bible, two, a list of everything you've done in life, I could put together a pretty compelling Motion to Exclude each and every one of you from Heaven. Would probably be a lot easier than most of the motions I've concocted thus far.
Of course, this reasoning is off the wall too. I'll let Hitchens deal with it appropriately:
First, which mere primate is so damn sure that he can know the mind of god? Second, would this anonymous author want his views to be read by my unoffending children, who are also being given a hard time in their way, and by the same god? Third, why not a thunderbolt for yours truly, or something similarly awe-inspiring? The vengeful deity has a sadly depleted arsenal if all he can think of is exactly the cancer that my age and former “lifestyle” would suggest that I got. Fourth, why cancer at all? Almost all men get cancer of the prostate if they live long enough: it’s an undignified thing but quite evenly distributed among saints and sinners, believers and unbelievers. If you maintain that god awards the appropriate cancers, you must also account for the numbers of infants who contract leukemia.
But my recurring thought is this: Why one and not the other? Why "Put your faith in the good Lord Jesus Christ and all will be well" but not "Put your faith in the good Lord Jesus Christ...who, as we have every reason to believe from his autobiography, is rather upset with the way you've been managing your affairs this decade."
I don't know, guys. I'm a mere human. Can't possibly know this stuff. Won't tell anybody what to believe. Won't tell anybody how to believe. Won't tell anybody that their beliefs are correct or incorrect.
But I do know that when my doctor tells me that R-CHOP and a battery of drugs and maybe some radiation gives me the best chance to stay on this rock for another several decades, that's what I'm going to do. And I'll talk to God, I'll converse with God, I'll listen to God, and I'll pray to God. But you better believe I'm praying with my legs as well.
***
The best quote on religion that I've ever heard is from a movie:
The Kingdom of Heaven. I've never seen it. Can't even tell you where I first heard or read the quote. But once I did, it stuck with me. It goes as such:
I put no stock in religion. By the word religion I have seen the lunacy of fanatics of every denomination be called the will of god. I have seen too much religion in the eyes of too many murderers. Holiness is in right action, and courage on behalf of those who cannot defend themselves, and goodness. What god desires is here [points to head] and here [points to heart] and what you decide to do every day, you will be a good man - or not.
If there is a god who would take offense at such an approach to life, then that is a god with whom I would rather not associate. This is just...so simple. So pure. It's concerned with
you. Not others.
You. What
you decide to do every day. How
you act. What
you have in
your mind and in
your heart.
Because hell, that's all I can control right now: me. So I do, the best I can. And while I can't say I wake up and think about this quote from a movie I've never seen every morning and then try to live my life accordingly, I can say that this is how I try to live my life, and how that goal means more to me now more than ever.
I don't think I'm "amazing" or "inspiring" or "brave" or "courageous" or any other adjective you can come up with of which I'm not deserving. Here's what I think I am: I am me, the same guy you've all known for three years, or five, or ten, or twenty, who has been put in a unique situation and is dealing with it the best way he can while having no real clue exactly how to do that. I think most all of you would be capable of similar things. Maybe not the whole writing thing, but that's what I do for a living. I've surprised the hell out of myself these past few weeks; I'm sure you would as well. You can say what you want, and really, I'm flattered by some of the things people say even if only half the people mean it. But you will never succeed in convincing me that I'm anything special here. There's nothing wrong if you think that. It's just that I won't.
But when I hear stuff from people who say I'm "inspiring" or whatever, it does, honestly and truly, mean a lot to me. Because as I've said before, I've gotta deal with this thing either way. But if something I do because of it can have a positive impact on other people...well that's a bit of positive that didn't exist in the world prior to me creating it. And that's something.
Because part of what I do here, and part of what I try to do every day now when I'm not in public, when I'm not "performing," (for those of you who know what I mean by that), is live my life according to that stupid quote from the movie above. Sometimes, maybe God is watching. Sometimes, I'm the only one watching. But it doesn't matter whether I know or He knows - it's the same effect:
Just do the right thing.
I really don't think it matters if you do it because you think some higher being is going to cast you into the fiery depths of hell or because you're going to cast yourself into the figurative fiery depths of hell. I don't think we have to make a definitive choice. A man who does the right thing while staring down the barrel of a gun is hardly more virtuous as the man who does the right thing when nobody is watching.
So what does this mean in practice? I'm still figuring that out. But to me, it means getting up each day ("what you decide to do each day") and focusing not only on what I can do to get better, but never forgetting that I'm not the only dog in this fight. Sometimes that's as simple as getting in a quick workout to keep my heart healthy, or drinking a protein shake to rebuild some of my cells. Sometimes it's tossing up a blog post to let everyone know how I'm doing, because people do care or at least profess to care. Sometimes it's responding to an e-mail to thank somebody for taking the time to write to me.
It means doing the right thing. "Goodness," if you will. It means being nice to people even when I don't feel like it (I think I do this more now than I did before July 30th, but still). It means being sympathetic to people, even when they say things that I don't want to hear or do things that irritate me. Nobody knows how to respond to something like this. Everybody is trying their best. How can you blame people for that? I'm not the only one affected by this thing.
It means having courage on behalf of
those who cannot defend themselves.
It means having the strength, in your mind and in your heart, to do the right things. It can be what God desires; it can be what you desire. You can do it because you think God is watching or because you lost a parent far too young and you know he or she is up there watching you. But if you are good in your mind and good in your heart, if you are able to look back at what you do in a day, a week, a year, or a lifetime and be proud of it - really, genuinely proud of what you have accomplished, then what god could possibly object to that?
And that's what I try to do. I talk about this being a day-by-day battle, and it is precisely that. I wake up every day and try to do little things to get better. And you probably won't see a single moment of fear or weakness because I have none. Unless you count hair loss. I know my diagnosis, I know my prognosis. I know I'm in pretty not-terrible shape as far as cancer goes, which can only be characterized in degrees of terrible. And that helps. But I don't think about it to much. Because it all speaks to things that will be sorted out sometime after today. And I can't worry about that stuff. I can worry about two things because there are two things I can effectively control: me, today. I can't worry about God's master plan, I can't worry about why this happened, I can't even begin, as a mere mortal, to think I have things like this figured out. I mean, I guess I could worry about it, and I think about it to write posts and stuff...but I can't control it. So what's the point? I'd just drive myself crazy.
So what's the end game? "You will be a good man - or not." Am I? I don't know. I'll reserve my own thoughts on this. You all have your own. And I'm not even going to hazard a guess as to what the Big Guy Up There thinks. But I will tell you that I'm pretty comfortable with where I'm at right now. And that, when I go to bed each night, after writing down my thoughts here and saying my prayers, I don't have much on my mind that keeps me tossing and turning. Some people would kill for peace like that.
So my God Conclusion, if you haven't already figured it out, is that I have no conclusion. I'm not sure it's even possible. I really don't think it's necessary. And I think I've made a pretty good case for why it's reasonable.
Also, you have all just been lawyered. If you made it this far, congratulations. It took me a couple hours and over 3,700 words to write, I reached no conclusion and probably confused you in the process, and now you all owe me $1200. Thanks for playing.